This guy. Tarte's EmphasEYES Aqua-Gel Eyeliner in Plum. $18 for a pen, 0.003 oz.
Let me start off with a caveat - I don't really like gel liners, in general. They smudge in a few hours, no matter what kind of primer I use, and I just don't like the look of them. For a smudgy, smokey effect, I prefer pencils, and for clean lines, you can't beat liquid liners. I've tried just a couple of gel liners (L'oreal's HIP and Smashbox's version) but I didn't like them, and this was the last shot - I thought perhaps the pen form might suit me better. Not really.
|Flat tip, see? As soon as you press down with this, it'll smudge out - I think I must go through two or three turns of the pencil in order to line both eyes.|
|See how product clumps together in spots? And yes, I make my faces without noses. Noses on smiley faces look weird to me.|
So, if you're a gel liner person, I'd stick to the Bobbi Brown pots or the Stila smudge pots or all of the other popular gel creations. I really can't see this one working for anyone. Let me know if you've had better luck with it - this one generally sits unused and unloved in my case.